Your perfect NHL – Part 2

Updated: December 12, 2012

This is part two of this week’s “what would your perfect NHL look like?”

Tuesday – Part 1 (Season length and divisions)

Over the course of this week, I’m going to touch on each of the following topics, and get your opinions as well:

  • Season length
  • Point system
  • Number of playoff teams
  • Overtime/shootout
  • Conferences/divisions

Here are today’s topics:

Overtime/Shootout: Ties don’t belong in hockey, which is why I’m a fan of the shootout. Saying that, shootout don’t benefit every team. There are certain teams that just haven’t done well in shootouts over the years. Washington (30-42), Philadelphia (23-41) and Florida (30-55) all have struggled since the shootout was implemented. Then there are the teams that have excelled, like New Jersey (54-29), Pittsburgh (51-30) and Colorado (46-25).

I think the perfect NHL would keep the shootout, but it is the overtime that should be changed. After the third period ends, I would like to see a full intermission. Following that would be a 5-minute 4-on-4 overtime session. If no one scores, a 5-minute 3-on-3 session. If still tied, then go right to the shootout. The reason I’d want a full intermission is so they don’t have clean the middle of the ice prior to the shootout.

If you have other suggestions for how overtime/shootouts should be handled, please leave a comment.


Penalties in overtime: This is something that I think would have an impact. If a player takes a penalty late in overtime, I believe that team should have to go without a shooter in the shootout. For example, let’s say Steve Ott takes a penalty with 20 seconds remaining in overtime and neither team scores in those last 20 seconds. Buffalo would have to go with two shooters in the shootout. Ott could still be a shooter, but Buffalo would be at a disadvantage (as they should because they took a penalty) as they would have two shooters to the opponent’s three.

There have been occasions where teams will do anything toward the end of overtime just to try and get to a shootout. Penalties don’t carryover. This would prevent that.

In case you’re interested, Buffalo 43-37 in shootouts.

Please leave a comment with your thoughts. Part 3 will be published tomorrow and Friday we will review everything to see what the majority of fans prefer.

Leave a comment:

Loading Facebook Comments ...


  1. Mike Dimino

    December 12, 2012 at 12:27 PM

    Playoff rules in the regular season should be the same one now used in the playoffs: 20-minute periods of 5-on-5, sudden-death hockey. I would gladly play fewer games during the season to off-set this change, which would greatly increase the excitement of games that are tied after regulation.

  2. Jonathan Crawford via Facebook

    December 12, 2012 at 12:10 PM

    Shootouts should stay. They make the game so much more exciting. Overtime penalties also should not be carried over.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


Skip to toolbar