Nathan Gerbe scored on a penalty shot in the third period, narrowing the deficit to one and allowing Buffalo over eight minutes to tie the game.
With the goaltender pulled, the Sabres weren’t able to draw even. Buffalo lost it’s first game of the preseason, falling to a 1-1 record. Toronto improved to 3-2-1 during the preseason and they still have three exhibition games remaining.
The Leafs were able to beat Buffalo after losing to them on Saturday night by a 3-1 score. However, it is only preseason and Ryan Miller was not in net on Monday.
Drew Stafford scored the first goal of the game to put Buffalo up 1-0. Stafford’s power play goal came as a result of Clarke MacArthur’s penalty. A few minutes later, the Maple Leafs scored a power play goal of their own. Phil Kessel tied the game for Toronto, and then scored again towards the end of the first period, putting the Leafs up 2-1.
Early in the second period, Nathan Gerbe scored to tie the game at two. Toronto bounced right back and took a 3-2 lead. Nikolai Kulemin scored his second goal in as many nights.
Jhonas Enroth came in to relieve Patrick Lalime, who stopped 18 of 21 shots on the night. Enroth finished the night with 15 of 17 saves.
With under five minutes remaining in the second period, Jordan Leopold took a shot that evened the game at three.
Christian Hanson’s goal allowed Toronto to take a 4-3 lead. Just over a minute later, Kulemin scored his second of the night, opening the biggest lead of the game for either team.
The Sabres outshot the Leafs 39-38 in the loss. Stafford finished the night with three points.
The Sabres get right back into action on Tuesday night with they make a trip to Ottawa.